I agree that Grifff should not have made this nether, it will only cause problems. But mattwhi, you are a dick and should not be unbanned. Third chances don't happen.

brolly warned me once ill admit to that

You were banned before. You said you wouldn't do it again. You did. Case closed.

This is almost entrapment. If I would have stumbled across it I would have mined some. If the nether gets destroyed he should be unbanned. I however do not know the full story, just my thoughts about having a huge nether thats unprotected.

there is a difference cause i didnt know that we wernt allowed

So you didn't know that you weren't supposed to take pieces of the giant pit of unfarmable and extremely expensive material?

no i didnt know

...

Because that excuse is extremely retarded.