Per the challenge

topchef -

Collect 1 of every kind of cooked or crafted edible food (no raw food, zombie flesh, or super golden apples)

I started with all the foods listed in gamemode 1 that I could identify. I tried to turn in the challenge and it didn't work. I then proceeded to add any and all types of consumable items and still cannot seem to get the type correct.

As of my last trying my inventory had the following items

(item id) item name

(260) apple

(393) baked potato

(297) bread

(354) cake

(391) carrot

(366) cooked chicken

(350) cooked fish

(320) cooked porkchop

(357) cookie

(344) egg

(396) golden carrot

(360) melon

(103) melon

(335) milk

(282) mushroom stew

(394) poisonous potato

(392) potato

(400) pumpkin pie

(363) raw beef

(365) raw chicken

(349) raw fish

(367) rotten flesh

(319) raw porkchop

(375) spider eye

(364) steak

(353) sugar

(296) wheat

I am fully aware that the challenge says no raw food or rotten flesh. I am also aware that some of these items are not really considered food in terms of the game. I am out of ideas on what other food stuffs are present. My concern is that there is potential for the item IDs in the challenge to possibly be wrong in the config file. I have no way of checking that though. I have been adding items into my inventory as they come up.

2 questions

1. Are other players having this same issue?

2. Can an admin confirm the item ids for the challenge?

Solved the issue, the challenge criteria is incorrect

The Challenge took the following

(item id) item name

(393) baked potato

(297) bread

(354) cake

(366) cooked chicken

(350) cooked fish

(320) cooked porkchop

(357) cookie

(322) golden apple

(396) golden carrot

(282) mushroom stew

(400) pumpkin pie

(364) steak

It did indeed take a Golden Apple despite the challenge saying that it doesn't take a golden apple.

It was probably referring to the super golden apple you can make out of 8 gold blocks, not the one from 8 ingots.

Didn't actually know about creating the super golden apple, knew there were two but thought the second one was non-craft-able. Learn something new each day. Spent too much time on Tekkit Servers and didn't keep up with vanilla changes. Thanks.